Let’s first know the nutritional differences between tofu vs paneer, to understand why we shouldn’t be comparing them.
Tofu is a plant based protein rich food made from soybean. To prepare tofu, first the beans are soaked, cooked and crushed into a liquid. Tofu is made from soy milk just like cheese is prepared from milk. first the milk is coagulated using a coagulant. The “Whey” (liquid fragment) are strained out during pressing of the newly formed curd and tofu is what you get with whey as the by-product.
Paneer, on the other hand, is prepared from milk and is a common food used in Indian households. It is often prepared fresh at home, or is available in the market in packaged form. To prepare paneer, first milk is boiled, and then lemon/vinegar is added to it.
Now to lightly compare the two. Both tofu and paneer are excellent protein sources and are complete proteins with all essential amino acids in them. Paneer though has a higher protein content.
Particular regions in Asia consume tofu and other soy products, whereas in Indian subcontinent, paneer and other milk products are consumed more commonly.
Both are vegetarian foods. But someone opting for Vegan diet can opt for tofu instead of paneer. Also, tofu is a good option for lactose intolerant individuals.
Of course, because they are prepared from different food sources, they have a different taste and texture.
Tofu is a very rich source of iron as compared to paneer. Paneer is a source which is richer in calcium. Overall calorie wise paneer is much higher.
Now, what have we really got out of this comparison?
Is this how nutrition is studied?
Is this how you compare tofu vs paneer ? If you do, which is absolutely stupid, then what conclusion did you draw?
Just because two foods are protein rich, you don’t compare foods like this. World over food is not consumed on the basis of nutrients, but availability and culture. There are many regions in India, who haven’t even heard of tofu, and have been relishing paneer for centuries now.
Another stupid thing which is quite commonly heard is that if you want to go for weight loss, then tofu being a low fat option is best for you. Really? Which nutrition book are you studying?
Is this how weight loss diets are designed?
This means, millions of people who have never heard of tofu or have never consumed it before, can’t lose weight if they consume paneer?
Does the total quantity/calories & quality of your entire day’s food intake matters, or a single food, just because it has few extra calories?
This is not how we compare foods ever. People are just making these stupid comparisons and confusing others. Specially the dumb dieticians and diet websites or channels, do such unnecessary comparisons.
Imagine a dietician telling a Japanese, who has been consuming tofu and other soy products since birth to shift to paneer, as its richer in calcium and protein, and other one telling someone in Punjab, to stop having paneer as it has more fat, and instead shift to tofu, which is a low fat option.
Don’t be surprised, as such recommendations are not uncommon. Human stupidity has no limits.
Akshay Chopra is a renowned fitness professional, a speaker , a writer and the owner of Indias research based platform, Werstupid. He has been transforming lives, and has addressed many a people with motivational words. Known as the Encyclopaedia of Fitness Industry, his knowledge is unparalleled.
Smile designing is a dental procedure, which helps to create a beautiful natural-looking smile. It can do wonders by enhancing your dental appearance regardless of the original condition of the natural teeth. SMILE can change your day, and in today’s time, your face and maybe your life too. With the change in times there is […]
How is it different from normal PCOS? Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is not a disease but a combination of multiple diseases forming a syndrome. Adolescent PCOS is a difficult diagnosis to reach and start treatment thereafter. Nearly 6-18% of adolescent females are diagnosed with PCOS, with this proportion being just the tip of an iceberg. […]
Working out in the nature once a while can do wonders to your fitness regime. Not only does it change your mood, it is innovative and it enhances your stamina also. Working out in the pleasant weather can be great fun, and for many it’s a ritual that has innumerable benefits. Running, Yoga, CrossFit, Bodyweight […]